Entertaining Cocktails
Two glasses of a red cocktail garnished with herbs, representing mixology 101 and the art of making cocktails at home.

Cocktails

Mixology 101: Avoid These 9 Mistakes When Making Cocktails at Home

Updated On:

Inside: Mixology 101 cocktail making tips. Learn how to avoid 9 common mistakes and create flawless drinks like a pro.

H ey there, cocktail enthusiasts! Ready to up your mixology game? 🍸

Whether you’re shaking things up for a party or just mixing a drink to unwind, I’ve got some killer cocktail making tips to share in this Mixology 101 guide.

From avoiding rookie mistakes to nailing the perfect pour, these 9 tips will have you crafting drinks like a pro in no time.

We’ve all had those “oops” moments—trust me, I’ve been there. But with a few tweaks and a little know-how, you’ll be making cocktails that’ll wow your friends and leave you feeling like a true mixologist. Cheers! 🥂

A hand holds a cocktail glass with a lemon slice while a shadow of another hand is seen in the background, illustrating the concept of making cocktails at home.

Note: Some of the links below are affiliate links, which means I might earn a small commission if you love something as much as I do. But I only recommend what I actually like myself.

Mistake 1: Not Using Ice (Or Enough Ice)

You know there’s a secret ingredient in every single cocktail? WATER. 😅

Okay, embarrassing confession time: I used to make the WORST cocktails at home. Like, way too strong and nothing like what you get at a bar. I tried so hard, but they just never tasted right.

One day, my boyfriend (now hubby) decided we should make a cocktail together. I poured the ingredients, gave it a good stir, and was about to grab the glasses when he stopped me. “Whoa, whoa, what about the ice?” he asked.

I shrugged and said, “Eh, that’s optional.”

He laughed and said it was absolutely NOT optional. Like, not even close.

via GIPHY

Turns out, ice isn’t just there to make your drink cold. When you stir or shake it, the ice melts a bit and adds water to your cocktail. A hidden ingredient! 🧊✨

Your cocktail isn’t complete until that melted ice dilutes the drink just right.

A cocktail sits on ice, showing that ice dilution is a critical step in home bartending

Looking back, I can’t believe I made such a silly mistake for SO long. But honestly, if you check most cocktail recipes, they don’t even mention ice! It’s just assumed, and they only tell you to stir or shake. 🤦‍♀️

Once I started adding ice, my drinks were a game changer. I finally felt like I was good at making cocktails.

So here’s the deal: After you mix your ingredients, ALWAYS add lots of ice before shaking or stirring (unless the recipe says otherwise) to get that perfect dilution. Then, strain your drink right away (don’t let it sit too long or it’ll get watery). 🥃

And that brings us to another common mistake…

Mistake 2: Not Stirring/Shaking for Long Enough

We know to add ice to make great cocktails, but are you giving it a quick shake or stir and moving on? Not so fast. (Literally.) 😜

Let me tell you about my good friend, Joelle. She’s as obsessed with cocktails as I am—always dissecting flavors and experimenting with our orders at cocktail bars. But whenever we made drinks at her place, she always asked ME to mix them. 🤔

Finally, I had to ask, “What’s the deal?” She confessed her cocktails were terrible, no matter what she tried.

Remembering my own cocktail epiphany, I asked if she was mixing with ice. She said yes.

So we decided to make one together. She did add ice, but just barely, and she hardly stirred it. Ah, there’s the problem! 🙃

With just an extra 30 seconds of stirring, her drinks were suddenly delicious.

A man's 2 hands are stirring 2 mixing glasses showing that stirring a cocktail is a critical step in bartending and properly making cocktails at home

So, how long should you stir or shake your drink?

Bottom line: After you add ice, shake or stir your drink for a full 30-45 seconds. Then strain it immediately. 🕰️🍸

And speaking of shaking and stirring…

Mistake 3: Shaking when you should be stirring (or vice versa)

First off, I’ll admit it—I’m a total cocktail snob. But, picture this: I walk into a bar, craving an Old Fashioned. I order one, and to my horror, the bartender combines the ingredients, then shakes them like it’s a dance-off, and serves up my drink with this proud layer of foam on top. 🤦‍♂️

Ever had a creamy Old Fashioned? Yeah, me neither. Because that’s not an Old Fashioned anymore. That’s a whole different vibe. Because, let’s get real, Old Fashioneds are stirred, not shaken.

A cocktail shaker and alcoholic drink sit on a table, representing mixology basics

And stirring vs shaking? Totally changes the game. Shaking turns it into this creamy, cloudy, frothy concoction instead of that clear, sharp classic we know and love.

So, when do you stir vs shake your drink?

Simple rule of thumb: if your drink’s got fruit juice in it, you shake it. Otherwise, you stir. 🍋

Mistake 4: You’re Skipping Bitters

I’m about to let you in on a little secret: I never travel without a bottle of bitters in my purse. Yep, you heard that right. Bitters, in my purse. 🤫

Let me tell you a story. I was on a work trip once, and we decided to hit up the hotel bar for a drink. Now, it wasn’t exactly a craft cocktail haven, so I played it safe and ordered bourbon on the rocks.

But here’s where it gets interesting—I whipped out this tiny bottle of Black Walnut purse bitters, squeezed a few drops into my drink with a dropper, and then casually slipped the bottle back into my purse. 😎

I looked up and noticed everyone was staring at me like I’d just performed a magic trick. Finally, someone mustered up the courage to ask, “Did you just poison your own drink?”

I couldn’t help but laugh. I made them do a taste test—bourbon alone vs. bourbon with bitters. And let me tell you, jaws dropped at the difference it made. Suddenly, everyone wanted to know where they could get their hands on their own little bottle of magic potion.

3 cocktail bitters sit on a home bar counter are how to make drinks at home

And here’s another trick for you: on an airplane, you can turn a tiny bottle of whiskey into an Old Fashioned with just a bottle of Angostura bitters and some stuff you can scrounge up on the plane (sugar and ice). That’s it. That’s the power of bitters, folks. 🌟

Bottom line: When you’re mixing cocktails, it’s easy to think, “Oh, it’s just a few drops of bitters, I’ll skip it.” But DON’T. Bitters pack a punch of rich flavor and can totally transform a drink. Trust me on this one. 🍹

Mistake 5: You’re Skimping on The Sugar

Okay, let’s talk about sugar in drinks. We all know it’s there, and it’s oh-so tempting to either cut it in half or, dare I say it, skip it altogether. 🍹

I’ll admit, there was a time when I’d skimp on the simple syrup, thinking, “Eh, what’s the harm? It’s a little healthier, right?”

But here’s the thing: cocktail recipes are like a precise science experiment. It’s no accident that every fruity cocktail comes with some form of sweetness—whether it’s a simple syrup or a sweet liqueur. It’s all about that perfect balance of sweet and acidic where the magic really happens. Mess with that balance, and you’ll end up with a drink that’s too sharp, too acidic, or just plain bad. 😬

a bottle of simple syrup sits on a gray counter next to a cocktail jigger, showing that sugar is a critical part of balancing cocktails when making drinks at home

Take the margarita, for example. Could you even imagine cutting the sugar? You’d be left with nothing but the tartness of lime and the bitterness of tequila. It’s like a whole different drink, and trust me, not in a good way.

So instead of skimping on the sugar, think of your cocktail as a dessert. I mean, would you ever decide on a whim that cake shouldn’t have sugar in it? Of course not! Because then it wouldn’t be cake anymore, right? It’s the same deal with cocktails.

Bottom line: Sugar is a crucial part of the cocktail experience, so don’t be shy with it. If you’re worried about your sugar intake, maybe consider an alternative drink altogether, or just sip on those well-crafted cocktails a bit more slowly. 🍰🍸

Mistake 6: Not Juicing Your Own Fruit

Alright, let’s talk about juice. Now, I get it—it’s tempting to reach for that bottle of store-bought lemon juice in your fridge. No messy peels, no lemon squirts in the eye. Sounds pretty good, right? 🍋

But here’s the kicker: store-bought juice tastes nothing like the real deal. And let me tell you, when it comes to flavor, your cocktails are gonna take a hit.

lemons sit on a cutting board on top of a checkered tablecloth. making fresh juice is a mixology 101 must

Here’s why fresh juice reigns supreme: it hasn’t had time to oxidize. See, store-bought juice has been hanging out in its bottle long enough to get cozy with oxygen from the air, and that leads to oxidation. And you know what oxidation does? It breaks down those enzymes in the fruit that give it that fresh, zesty flavor. (Same process that turns your apple brown after you slice it, y’know?)

Bottom line: Sure, juicing those lemons and limes might feel like a chore, but trust me, it’s worth it. Say no to the store-bought stuff and invest in a squeezer. Your cocktails will thank you. 🍋

Mistake 7: Free Pouring

Alright, listen up. If your cocktail pouring technique even remotely resembles Tom Cruise in “Cocktail,” we need to have a chat.

via GIPHY

One, because we might just need to be best friends. And two, because your pouring technique needs a serious upgrade. 🍹

I don’t care how confident you are in your free pouring skills—trust me, it’s not worth it.

(BTW, free pouring is basically just eyeballing the amount of each ingredient without measuring.)

a man making a cocktail at home is measuring the alcohol in a jigger before pouring it into the cocktail mixing glass

In a world where EVERYTHING about cocktail making is so precise, I’m honestly baffled why free pouring is a thing. But get this—even here in NYC, at this super fancy cocktail bar I love, I recently witnessed a bartender ditching his jigger and going for the free pour. I was shook.

Bottom line: When it comes to making cocktails, precision is key. Always measure your ingredients precisely. Bust out that jigger and leave the free pouring to the amateurs. 🥃

Mistake 8: Not Putting the Top Back on your Bottles Immediately

Ever had that soul-crushing moment when you whip up a batch of killer cocktails for your friends, basking in how amazing they taste, only to wake up the next day and realize you forgot to put the caps back on the bottles? 😱

Yep, been there, done that. And let me tell you, it’s a tragedy. All those beautiful spirits, now oxidized and stripped of their flavor forever. 💔

several alcohol drink bottles sit on a table with all of the caps on to keep the liquor fresh, a mixology 101 tip

Bottom line: Make it a habit to slap those caps back on your bottles as soon as you’re done pouring. Trust me, it’s a small step that’ll save you from some serious cocktail heartbreak. 🥃💔

Mistake 9: Keeping Your Liquor in the Freezer

Raise your hand if you keep your liquor in the freezer. 🙋‍♂️

Alright, I’m going to need you to walk over to that freezer and take those bottles out.

I know, it’s super common. A lot of people do it. But here’s the deal: when liquor gets cold, it suppresses the taste of the alcohol. So sure, if you’re a college student trying to chug cheap vodka before a frat party, go ahead and keep it in the freezer. 🥶

alcohol bottles sitting in a freezer, losing their flavor. this is a mixology 101 tip to never keep your liquor in the freezer

But if you’re all about experiencing the full-bodied flavor of a cocktail, you want those bottles at room temperature.

Mixing your drink with ice (see tip #1!) is what chills your cocktail to a refreshing temp without messing with the flavor of the alcohol. 🍹

Bottom line: Keep your liquor bottles on a shelf at room temperature, not in the freezer, to enjoy the best, fully developed flavors. Cheers! 🥂

Time To Put These Mixology 101 Tips To Use

And there you have it, cocktail aficionados! With these cocktail making tips, you’re on the path to becoming a true mixology master. 🍸✨

Remember, it’s all about the finer details—precise measurements, room temp bottles, and never skimping on the sugar or bitters.

a woman holding an alcoholic drinks, showing how easy it is to make cocktails for beginners

Next time you mix a drink, embrace these tips and watch your creations soar from good to extraordinary. Cheers to crafting cocktails that not only taste amazing but also leave a lasting impression! 🍹🥂

Now, go out there and shake up something spectacular. You’ve got this! 🌟🍸

Next Up, You You’ll Probably Like…

Leave a Comment

Hey There

I'm Stefanie—Founder & Writer for Revel & Delight

I believe the secret to hosting exceptional gatherings, from lively celebrations to cozy get-togethers, is thoughtfulness and a little bit of prep. Craft the right atmosphere, attitude, then then sit back and savor the moment you've made.

Get on the list

Join the Email Waitlist

Want a weekly cocktail making tip? The email list is still being prepared, but sign up here to be the first one to receive cocktail making tips, party hosting ideas, and free printables.