Inside: Is your vermouth ruining your cocktails? Learn which ones cocktail enthusiasts say are must-haves, the ones to avoid, and the simple storage trick that’ll improve your drinks.
W hen it comes to crafting the perfect cocktail, vermouth is like that quietly competent friend who holds everything together.
Sure, it may not seem like the show-stopper like gin or bourbon, but ignore it, and your drinks will pay the price.
I used to grab the cheapest vermouth I could find and call it a day—big mistake. Once I upgraded to better bottles (and actually started taking care of them the right way), my cocktails went from “meh” to my friends literally stopping me me mid-conversation to rave about my cocktail.
Trust me, vermouth can be a game-changer, if you know what kind to buy.
Let’s dive into why vermouth is so important, how to treat it with the respect it deserves, and which brands you’ll want to invite to your bar… and which ones to ghost.

pin it to remember

Table of Contents
Note: Some of the links below are affiliate links, and just so you know, I earn from qualifying purchases through Amazon and some other cool programs. Thanks for the support, party pal!
What’s the Big Deal with Vermouth?
Vermouth might seem like a filler ingredient—an afterthought next to your shiny bottles of tequila or rum—but trust me, it’s the secret sauce that makes your drink sing. Made from fortified wine and infused with botanicals, vermouth can enhance flavors, add depth, and take your cocktails from “fine” to “fantastic.”
BUT… (and it’s a big but…) not all vermouths are created equal. Some are divine nectar; others taste like regret.
Here’s everything you need to know.
📍How I Chose These Vermouths
This list isn’t just a collection of personal opinions (though I wholeheartedly agree with the picks & it’s what I use at home). It’s based on an analysis of what cocktail enthusiasts are raving about on Reddit. By diving into the collective wisdom of the internet’s most dedicated drink makers, I’ve distilled (pun, def intended) the best and worst vermouths for your cocktail needs.
The Best Vermouths: Cocktail Royalty
Without further ado, here are the winners. Yes, there are 2 winners for best sweet vermouth.
Best Sweet Vermouth: Cocchi Vermouth di Torino
Rich and flavorful, Cocchi Vermouth di Torino is a go-to for sweet vermouth. Its balanced profile makes it an excellent choice for Negronis, Manhattans, and more. Cocktail enthusiasts swear by it for its versatility and complexity.
(other) Best Sweet Vermouth: Carpano Antica Formula
Known for its bold vanilla notes, Carpano Antica Formula is luxurious and complex. While it’s a favorite for Manhattans, its strong flavor can sometimes overshadow lighter cocktails. Use it wisely, and it’ll elevate your drinks to new heights.

Best Dry Vermouth: Dolin
Dolin earns high marks for both its sweet and dry vermouths. Affordable and versatile, it’s a staple for home bars. Whether you’re stirring up a martini or crafting a classic cocktail, Dolin delivers consistent quality.
Honorable Mentions:
- Punt e Mes: With its assertive bitterness, Punt e Mes is a top pick for cocktails that call for a more complex and adventurous flavor.
- Cinzano: A budget-friendly option that doesn’t skimp on quality, Cinzano offers a pleasant profile for those seeking value without sacrificing taste.
The Worst Vermouths: Approach with Caution
Not all vermouths are created equal, and some are better left on the shelf. While these bottles might be common finds, they often fall short in delivering the complexity and balance your cocktails deserve.
Here’s what to watch out for:
Worst Sweet Vermouth: Martini & Rossi Sweet Vermouth
Widely available but divisive, M&R Sweet Vermouth often gets dinged for tasting more like oregano than elegance. Pizza notes are great… in your pizza.
Worst Dry Vermouth: Gallo Dry Vermouth
This one’s sweeter than it should be, and its herbal notes leave much to be desired. Use it only if there’s literally nothing else around.
How to Keep Your Vermouth Fresh (and Your Cocktails Fabulous)
Buying the right brand is only the first step to good vermouth. The second is keeping it fresh. Vermouth, being wine-based, can lose its flavor quickly if not stored properly. Follow these tips to ensure your vermouth stays in top shape:
- Store in the Fridge: Vermouth oxidizes quickly once opened. Keep it cold to slow down the degradation.
- Use a Wine Pump: Removing air from the bottle prevents oxidation and keeps flavors intact. This is the one I have, and love it because it has 4 tops included.
- Buy Smaller Bottles: Unless you’re hosting nightly cocktail parties (no judgment), opt for half bottles to ensure freshness.
- Batch Cocktails: Mix up a batch of Negronis or Manhattans and store them in the freezer. This not only preserves the vermouth but also saves you time when cocktail hour rolls around.
Vermouth 101: Key Questions Answered
Why is vermouth important?
Vermouth adds complexity, balance, and a touch of magic to your cocktails. Without it, your Manhattan is just whiskey with a splash of sadness.
Should I use different vermouths for different drinks?
Absolutely. Sweet vermouth (red) and dry vermouth (white) are the main types, and they’re not interchangeable. Sweet vermouth shines in classics like the Manhattan or Negroni, while dry vermouth is a must for martinis and other crisp concoctions.
How do I store vermouth?
Unlike spirits, vermouth is wine-based, which means it goes bad quicker. Once opened, store it in the fridge and use a wine vacuum to suck out the air after each pour. Pro tip: Buy half bottles instead of full ones so you can finish them before they lose their mojo.
Do I need to spend big bucks on vermouth?
Not necessarily. A great vermouth doesn’t have to break the bank, but ultra-cheap options often lack depth and quality. Invest wisely, and your cocktails will thank you.
Why not just get the cheapest one?
Because life’s too short for bad martinis, that’s why. Skimping on vermouth to save money for fancy spirits is like putting ketchup on a gourmet steak—you’ll ruin the whole experience.
Final Thoughts: Choose Wisely, Sip Happily
Whether you’re mixing up up a martini or stirring a Negroni, the right vermouth can make all the difference. Don’t skimp, and don’t forget to treat it with care. Pick a bottle that suits your palate, store it properly, and enjoy your cocktails as they’re meant to be—balanced, flavorful, and absolutely delightful.
A Year of Parties, Planned for You.

Get your free guide with 48 party themes and signature cocktails so good, your friends will RSVP in seconds. Plus you’ll get my weekly email.
Next Up, You You’ll Probably Like…
- Ina Garten’s genius trick for evaluating a new bar
- Always have a signature cocktail at your fingertips with my cocktail & party planning tips on my email list
- Try this trending new happy hour food pairing idea at home
- Get 5 tips to plan better parties (with less stress)
- How to set up a DIY Aperol Spritz bar (plus a free drink sign)